Every now and again the Hallmark channel will turn out an interesting movie. Not good, mind you (something that given the limitations of the Hallmark formula is too much to ask), but interesting. As directed by actress/filmmaker Lucie Guest, THE NIGHTS BEFORE CHRISTMAS (2026) is standard Hallmark fare in many respects, bearing a soundtrack filled with old-timey holiday standards, Vancouver scenery unconvincingly filling in for New York City, and a trite, feel-good narrative arc.
What’s unusual is the provocative GROUNDHOG DAY (1993) inspired premise, and the fact that, in contrast to most Hallmark movies, it has a male protagonist: Marty (the veteran Hallmark hunk Tyler Hynes), a movie theater manager whose days “have all started to feel the same.” One Christmas Eve he makes a heartfelt wish for “more time” and finds himself reexperiencing the previous day—at least until midnight, at which point he awakens to once again relive Christmas Eve.
This grants Marty the extra time he so desires, and he uses it to his advantage, reading a biography of Edgar Allan Poe, learning different languages and making gingerbread houses (a skill of paramount importance in Hallmark holiday movies). He also meets Chloe (Laci J. Mailey), a pretty young woman Marty finds crying in an alley.
Chloe initially blows off his advances, but on his next go-around Marty turns up with gingerbread ice cream, which renders her a bit more receptive. Following a sequence related from Chloe’s point of view, showing that her Christmas Eve has been a rotten one involving burnt food and a missed flight (representing the outermost limits of trauma allowed by Hallmark), the two have a coffee shop meeting in which Marty concludes that he feels “something I haven’t felt for a woman in a long time.”
You can guess how this romance ultimately works out, but what’s interesting is how it disrupts Marty’s existence. He finds that a single day (even a repeated one) isn’t nearly enough to properly savor his newfound love, and continually tries to extend his time with Chloe—and find a way out of the time loop in which he’s inextricably stuck. The solution? He’ll apparently need to hew to the spirit of the season, and learn to be more selfless in his demeanor.
The shoddy production design (with nondescript interiors decked out with Christmas decorations that fail to liven them up) and TV commercial worthy lighting bespeak this film’s Hallmark orientation (upon which quickly and cheaply are the major filmmaking operatives). Yet THE NIGHTS BEFORE CHRISTMAS has a livelier drive than most such fare, with split screen, montage editing and propulsive action movie pacing greatly enhancing the formulaic proceedings.
Most importantly, the film never sells out its science fictionish premise, which isn’t presented as a quickly discarded rom-com lead-in or a symbolic springboard, but as a fully thought-out occurrence that’s taken seriously. Again, this doesn’t make for a good film, but if you’re ever forced to sit through a Hallmark movie, this is the obvious choice.
Vital Statistics
THE NIGHTS BEFORE CHRISTMAS
Hallmark
Director: Lucie Guest
Screenplay: Russell Hainline
Cinematography: Graham Talbot, Nelson Talbot
Editing: Freyda Maude
Cast: Tyler Hynes, Laci J. Mailey, Oscar Chark, Deborah Finkel, Jace Fleming, Davin Tong, Alan Ramon Ward